If you are looking for an Induction Stove, firstly, you must compare it with your existing gas stove. You should check whether it will be beneficial for you in terms of Cost, Operation, Maintenance, Safety. Comparison of Induction Stove vs Gas Stove is a crucial step before you invest more in buying one.
As the cost of petroleum is increasing day by day, the price of LPG, Petrol, Diesel is also increasing. The cost of the LPG cylinder is high and fluctuating.
On the other hand, the cost of electricity almost steady with varying unit rates from Rs 1.2 to 13 depending upon the slab. Whereas, for domestic usage, the unit rate of electricity usually varies from Rs 1.2 to 6.
The average electricity unit rate for domestic usage is around Rs 5 across India. The power consumption by an Induction cooker depends upon the wattage consumed.
The following comparison table of Induction Stove and Gas Stove can surely help you consider various options like safety, operation, cost, energy efficiency before you make any decision to buy.
Induction vs Gas Stove – Comparison
|Features||Induction Stove||Gas Stove|
|Cooking Environment||Does not heat||Heats up faster|
|Weight and Space Requirement||Low||High|
|Cookware Compatibility||Needs only ferromagnetic flat-bottom cookware||No such limitations|
|Use of Cooling Fan when Cooking||Can be used||Cannot be used|
|Cleaning and Maintenance||Low||High|
|Harmful Gas Emission||Does not emit harmful gases||Produces Carbon Monoxide, Formaldehyde, Nitric Oxide, and Nitrogen-di-Oxide.|
|Ease of Use||Medium Difficulty||Very Easy|
|Our Recommendation||Philips Viva Collection HD4928/01 2100-Watt Induction Cooktop||Pigeon by Stovekraft Favourite Glass Top 3 Burner Gas Stove|
How the Induction stove is different than the Gas stove?
1. Working Principle
An Induction Stove works on the principle of Electromagnetic Induction. In this process, Electricity is converted to Heat Energy that is used to cook food. The best induction cooktops in India are highly efficient with an easy operating procedure.
On the other hand, The gas stove works on the principle of Combustion. Here Chemical Energy from LPG gas is converted to heat energy by burning the gas.
2. Energy Efficiency
This is one of the most important factors when you compare an Induction Stove vs Gas Stove. As the Induction Stove works on the principle of Electromagnetic Induction, without a flat iron base of the pot, it does not work.
With electromagnetic induction, the magnetic field of the cooktop induces another magnetic field on the iron base of the induction stove. Around 80-90% of energy is effective to induce the magnetic field on the pot. Very minimal energy is lost during the process.
Thus it increases the efficiency of the Induction Stove.
The Gas Stove heats up the cooking pot with flame generated by burning the LPG gas. Around 40-50% of the energy generated by it is effective to heat up the pot for cooking. Therefore, Gas Stoves are less efficient than Induction stoves in terms of Energy Efficiency.
3. Safety for Cooking
Safety is a very crucial factor when determining which is better- Induction Stove or Gas Stove.
As no flame is generated by an Induction Stove during cooking, it provides you maximum safety. No fire or burning hazard is there during cooking. However, you should not touch the heated surface of the Cooktop just after cooking.
Those who have a pacemaker, are not advised to use an Induction Stove as there might be a magnetic interference that could lead to malfunction of the pacemaker.
During cooking with a gas stove, there could be a chance for burn or catching fire whether there is a misoperation, unsafe handling, or leakage of LPG from the cylinder, gas pipe, or regulator. Moreover, the cooking environment also gets hot when using a gas stove.
Hence, when safety is concerned, an Induction Cooktop is recommended over the Gas stove. The best auto-Ignition gas stoves do not require to light up manually and can help the user to the largest extent.
4. Weight and Space Requirement
A gas stove has multiple components to install and place in your kitchen. The main components of a Gas Stove set consist of- an LPG cylinder, regulator, gas pipe, burner/ oven. Overall it is huge to keep in your kitchen in terms of size, space, and weight.
However, on the contrary, an Induction Stove is a single component with far less size, space, and weight. All you need is a 2 phase electrical plug point near the place where you want to keep the Induction Stove.
5. Comfort when Cooking
In the long run, comfort is the most essential factor while you select between an Induction Stove and a Gas Stove.
For an Induction Stove, you can get the most comfort when using it. Whereas, cooking with a gas stove is less comfortable as there is a heated environment, more chance for burn and catching fire.
6. Cleaning and Maintenance
While you compare Induction Stove vs Gas Stove, maintenance is a crucial factor to determine ease of handling. More maintenance means more headaches.
A gas stove is a high maintenance prone. Whereas, an Induction Stove is less maintenance intensive as it has fewer components to maintain.
7. The capital Cost
For a gas stove, there are a lot more components when compared to an Induction Stove. The total cost is significantly higher for a Gas Stove. But, for an Induction Stove, the price is considerably less.
If the price is concerned, you should go for an Induction Stove. A good Induction Stove will cost you between Rs 1500-3000. Whereas, A gas stove with 2 burners will cost you Rs 2000-4000.
8. Recurring Costs for Induction and Gas Stoves
To calculate the recurring cost, let us assume boiling 10 L of water from 25°C to 100°C on an induction cooktop and a gas stove separately.
We know that, Absorbed Energy= Mass x Specific Heat x Change in temperature
Mass of 10 L water = 10 Kg
Specific heat of water= 4.18 J/g°C
Change in temperature= 75°C
Therefore, Energy needed to heat water from 25°C to 100°C= (10 x 4.18 x 75) kJ or 3135 kJ
Whichever source you use (induction or gas stove), it must generate 3135 kJ of energy to heat 10 L water to 100°C.
The cost of Electricity depends on the slab and the corresponding unit rate. To understand in detail, let us consider that we need to heat up 10 L of water.
For an Induction Stove, if it runs for 1 hour with the 2000 watt power setting, it will consume approximately 2 kWh of electricity. Considering a medium range of slab with the unit rate of Rs 5/ KWh, it will cost you around Rs 10.
Let us assume to use 2000 watts of power on the induction cooktop to boil 10 L of water.
But assuming 90% efficiency, effective power= 1800 watts or 1.8 kW
Approx time taken to boil water= 3135/(1.8*60) or 29 minutes.
Electricity consumed= (2*29)/60 = 0.96 kWh or units
If the electricity cost in your area is Rs 5/unit, then,
Cost of boiling 10 L water on induction cooktop= 4.8 INR
On the other hand, an LPG cylinder will cost you around Rs 600 if you have a subsidy. If you don’t have a subsidy, it might cost you around Rs 800. You can check the latest price of the LPG cylinder in your city HERE.
The calorific value of LPG is around 46 MJ/Kg
Ideal mass of LPG to be used to boil 10 L water= 3135/46000 = 0.068 Kg
Considering the efficiency of the gas stove to be around 50%, the actual LPG consumption is 0.136 Kg
The price of a 14.2 Kg cylinder varies for different states in India.
Assuming an average LPG price of Rs 600 (subsidized) and Rs 800 (non-subsidized), we find that,
Cost of boiling 10 L water on the gas stove (approx.)
- subsidized consumers= 5.74 INR
- non-subsidized consumers= 7.66 INR
NOTE: The calculation is valid on the assumed standard parameters.
The recurring cost for cooking with an Induction Cooktop is much lower than cooking with a gas stove. Thus, we can conclude that induction cooking is cheaper than using a gas cylinder. The following table is based on boiling of 10 L of Water from 25°C to 100°C.
|Parameter||Induction Cooktop||Gas Stove|
|3744 kJ||3128 kJ|
|4120 kJ||6258 kJ|
|Power and Fuel Consumption||0.96 units of electricity||0.136 Kg LPG|
|Cost||4.8 INR||5.74 INR (subsidized)|
7.66 INR (non-subsidized)
Pros and Cons of Induction Cooktops and Gas Stoves
Induction Stove Benefits
- Induction cooktops are more efficient in performance than gas stoves.
- They are safer than gas stoves as no fire is involved for cooking.
- The electric cooktops need a limited working space compared to gas stoves.
- Operating an induction cooktop is very comfortable as there is no heat generated due to fire.
- Frequency, time and effort for cleaning and maintenance of induction cooktops is low.
- Cost of an induction cooktop is not very high making it affordable to everyone.
- Significantly low recurring cost compared to gas stoves.
- Induction stoves heat faster and distribute heat more evenly to the cookware.
- Available with programmable temperature controls.
- Very little heat is wasted during cooking.
- The generated heat is transferred to the cookware only inside the circled area on the cooktop. Thus, the cooktop body stays cool.
- As no fuel is burnt; carbon monoxide, Formaldehyde and nitrogen-di-oxide are not produced.
Induction Stove Limitations
- Can only be used with cookwares with ferromagnetic materials. Aluminium, copper and bronze cookwares are not suitable.
- You can only use utensils with flat bottom. Maximizing the surface contact is the key for efficient induction cooking.
- You cannot cook on an induction stove if there is a power supply problem or voltage fluctuation.
- Elders with a pacemaker should not operate an induction stove as the electromagnetic field can affect it negatively.
Gas Stove Benefits
- Gas stoves are easier to use than induction cooktops.
- Power cut or voltage fluctuation does not affect cooking.
- Using a gas stove can let you control the cooking necessities more.
- No specific type of utensil required for gas stoves.
- Gradual heating allows us to guess the temperature of the heated cookware, whereas the induction stove sets the exact temperature of cooking.
Gas Stove Limitations
- Cooking on gas stoves involve fire hazard. It can cause burn if the user is not attentive.
- Lower energy efficiency than induction cooktops.
- It can heat the oven and kitchen environment which can be uncomfortable during the summer.
- You cannot use a ceiling fan or pedestal fan while cooking on gas stove.
- As LPG/ CNG burns during cooking; it releases PM2.5 particulate, Carbon Monoxide, Formaldehyde, Nitric Oxide and Nitrogen-di-Oxide to the environment affecting the health of the user.
- Gas stoves need significant area to place the oven, cylinder and gas pipe.
- They need more effort and time for cleaning and maintenance.
- The recurring cost for gas stove is more than that of induction cooktops.
Frequently Asked Questions about Induction and Gas Stoves
Yes, Induction cooking is much better than gas cooking in terms of recurring cost, safety, maintenance, space requirement, cooking environment, and ease of maintenance. An Induction Cooktop is a better alternative than gas stoves today with fluctuation in LPG price.
Yes, an Induction Cooktop is cheaper than a gas stove when your concern is both the capital and recurring cost. With a unit rate of Rs 5, you can save Rs 1.92 to boil 10 L water when using an Induction Cooktop.
Induction cooking is safe for health as there is no naked flame. But if you have a pacemaker, you should not use it as the electromagnetic field might cause a negative effect.
You should use a flat bottom pot made of iron or steel (ferromagnetic) to cook efficiently with an Induction Cooktop.
Induction or Gas Stove? – Final Words
From the above calculation and comparison of gas stove vs induction stove, it is clear that if your electricity unit rate is around Rs 5/ KWh, an Induction Stove is very much economical compared to Gas Stove. However, for the higher slab, it might cost you equal to or more than a Gas Stove.
Considering the above points wisely, you may find that an induction stove is the best alternative to a gas stove in terms of Energy Efficiency, Safety, Space Requirements, comfort, maintenance, and Cost.
This video explains a lot about the differences between Induction Cooktops and Gas stoves. Check it out!
- Everything About Induction Cookware
- Best Kadai for Cooking in India
- How to Fix Yellow Flames on Gas Stoves?
- How to use aluminium utensils on induction stoves?
- Right Ways to Clean Gas Stove Burners
- How to Light up Gas Stoves with Electric Starters?
- Can you use a clay pot on the induction cooktop?
- Glass Top Vs Stainless Steel Gas Stove